Feature |
Vacuum plasma |
Flametreatment |
Corona /blown corona |
Openair® plasma |
| |
|
 |
 |
 |
| Description |
The plasma is formed in a sealed chamber at low pressures. Sometimes specialty gases are required like helium, argon or nitrogen |
This form of plasma requires the lowest level of technology. Burning gas generates a low concentration of plasma |
An electric discharge creates an arc, generating plasma. A current of air or gas can be used to blow the arc towards the work surface. In some cases the arc touches or penetrates the material |
The patented Openair® process generates a high density plasma inside a jet that is then directed onto the work surface |
| Special process gases required |
Specialty gases required |
No |
Air is generally used |
Air is used. For unusual applications a process gas might be used to add functionality |
| Energy consumption |
Low for small batches |
High. A lot of heat is produced, which can be disagreeable in summer |
Low, typically 300 Watts |
Low, 500 to 1000 Watts |
| Running cost |
Labor intensive, because of batch process |
Energy costs and venting costs because unit creates heat and humidity |
Low |
Low, only 10 to 20¢ per hour per jet for electricity and air |
| Temperature |
20 - 40°C |
Flame can be 900 - 1,000°C, surface is less |
Arc can be 1,500°C which can cause pitting and streamers |
Plasma beam is typically 40 - 125 °C. Surface of material can often rise 1
- 10°C |
| Voltage at material surface |
0 - 800 volts |
0 - 10 volts |
500 - 2,000 volts |
0 - 10 volts (or with a special jet to treat sensitive electronics less than 1 volt) |
| % plasma |
10 - 100% but due to vacuum actual plasma density is 200 times lower than Openair® plasma |
Less than 3% |
Likely less than 3% |
10% atomic oxygen at the exit from the jet |
| Wettability achievable (dynes/cm) |
70 |
30 - 70 |
40 - 60 |
60 - 120 |
| Suitability for in-line production |
Batch processes only |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
| Suitability for 3D components |
Yes |
Yes, but produces uneven results |
Uneven treatment, does not cover the inside of flanges |
Yes |
| Suitability for metal/plastic combinations |
Yes |
Yes, but not satisfactory for foam |
No - danger of arcing |
Yes |
| Treat thin walled containers |
Yes |
Thin walled moldings can warp and glass filled plastics develop a rough surface |
Can create pinholes in thin materials |
Yes |
| Safety |
Generally safe |
Flammable gas explosion hazard. Extra insurance costs |
Danger of electrical shock, burn and ozone toxicity |
Relatively safe |
| Emissions |
Depends on process gases used |
Can produce high concentrations of partially combusted organic compounds and greenhouse gases |
Produces ozone |
No ozone produced nor other pollutants |
| Suitability for high volume production |
No - a high labor batch process |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes can run at line speeds up to 3,000 feet per minute |
| Monitoring for quality control |
Yes |
Results vary with the composition of the gas and can vary through the year, and diminish when humidity is high |
Difficult to monitor |
Yes, suitable for QS9000, can verify treatment effectiveness |